The thing is, all these conversations about whether or not WILD is possible when you first go to sleep, overlook the fact that it might not just be REM sleep in which we dream.
What if it’s possible to dream in the first 1 or 2 stages of sleep? After all, they are light sleep. Just because you’re eyes aren’t moving doesn’t mean your brain’s not doing something.
Although I’ve never had WILD when first going to sleep at night, I have, very many times, awoken from from a short bit of sleep when first going to sleep and remember having some kind of dream experience.
It’s like, about 5 years ago, I remember the film Twin Peaks Fire Walk With Me being on, and I was recording it but also watching it in bed, and I fell asleep whilst watching it and woke up about half an hour later definately sure I had dreamt about it. How do I know it was a dream and not just me watching it whilst half asleep? Well, I was in it for a start!
So I think you have to break down the question of “can we WILD first thing at night” into what you’re actually asking. Are you asking more specifically if REM sleep can happen first thing at night? The answer is probably “no”. Are you asking if dreams can happen in stages of sleep other than REM? Then the answer is probably “yes”.
And then if you’re asking the more specific question, can WILD be induced when not in REM sleep, the answer is probably “yes, but it’s much much harder”.
I don’t know why you lot seam to have spent so much time dancing round the vague issue without actually asking the really important questions. The debate of whether or not WILD can happen first thing at night seams to, up until now, consisted mainly of comments like “Well I don’t think it’s possble because REM sleep doesn’t happen first thing at night” followed by comments like “Well it happened to me once.”
It’s like sombody saying, “I think it’s impossible to break a plank of wood in half without using a saw,” and then somebody else says, “Well I did it once by leaning it against a wall and jumping on it.” The answer is the same: it’s possible but harder.
Life is not a series of strict rules, it’s an endless continuum of possibilities…
Ed.