I am aware that the topic has been discussed throughoutly, and I’m sorry to say that I don’t have time to read it through, but here is my two cents.
First of, I’d like to thank you for this great technique. Even though I’ve only tried it this night, I’ve succeeded and tasted the great fruits of lucidity. And this is how it went:
I had alarm ring at 10am this morning to WBTB (with no intention to try this technique out), however, I awoke somewhere around 9am because of the heat in my room. I thought I had overslept greatly, but was pleasantly surprised when I saw what time it was. As I headed back to the land of counting sheep I remembered this tech, and began to move my fingers. Failure, I had not fallen asleep. Instead I chose to sleep normally, awakening when the alarm rung next I snoozed and tried for a total of three or four times to get lucid with this technique. The last attempt succeeded, and after moving my fingers for a short while I found myself looking at my minds precognition of the new LD4ALL layout (which I’m not going to describe here). I had no body and could not turn around, but after a while I thought “yes I have a body” and so I arose from a bed in which I had not fallen asleep. The dream continued from here as a normal lucid dream.
Futher I’d like to contribute with a small analysation of this techniqe, which you may or may not find boring as hell.
Simply put, HILD is a techniqe that almost works the same way as the WILD counting tech. It consists of one thing, an element that the mind can keep it’s concentration on while falling asleep. The only difference is what this element is.
The counting techique is a purely mental task, which is easy to drift away from as thoughts have a tendency to wander whenever you are not watching them.
This is the main problem with all these WILD techs, you lose concentration and consciousness and fall asleep normally. The other cause of failure is overdoing the action that is supposed to keep you concentrated, in turn waking you up or not letting you fall asleep (eventually giving up and going to sleep normally).
So let’s look at the HILD tech, instead of counting you move your fingers. This is a physical exercise rather than a mental one. What makes a physical exercise different from a mental one? Two things. One, it is a lot easier for it to wake you up if you concentrate on it to much. And two, it is very different when it comes to automatition. When you automate counting, your mind will drift and you will fall asleep. To success with counting, you have to keep it in your immediate consciousness and not let your mind wander. Automatition of a physical movement (of which breathing and heartbeting is natural, and I’m able to automate rapid eye-blinking, aswell as stop it entirely) is a lot different. You’r consciousness is immediately informed if there is any change in the status of your movement. Because we drift off into a dream the movement stops even though we don’t notice it, however, this constant movement keeps our brain informed of itself and lets our mind wander. This is not without risk for falling asleep normally, but the chance of failure is still smaller than that of counting.
As Hargart stated in his excellent tutorial, the longer you are awake (and moving your fingers) the more minimal the chance of succeeding with this techniqe is. Thus it is adviceable to use it in short Wake Back To Sleep moments in the night or morning.
To conclude, counting is (to me atleast) a lot less effective in the sense of keeping consciousness, but you can keep doing it for a long time without waking yourself up to the point of no (or small chance of) return. While HILD lets me keep just the right level of consciousness but has a slight dissadvantage in it’s awakening nature.
This most assuredly differs from person to person, but I find the balance of HILD a lot better than WILD counting.
Again, thankyou for taking your time to post this techniqe.