Here are some of my experiences after a month or so of trying to WILD:
1) Trying to WILD when first going to sleep
On the first few attempts, I tried counting. I usually got rapid heartbeat and irregular breathing after a few minutes. This got better in later attempts, mainly by changing my breathing technique (this was also mentioned somewhere in one of the earlier parts of the BIG WILD topic) and also by getting used to the strange feelings of deep relaxation.
The result of these attempts was a state of very deep relexation, in which sometimes hours seem to pass almost like minutes. However, I could not fall asleep while lying on my back, so I would eventually turn over.
After the first attempts, I often was much too excited to fall asleep and stayed awake for hours. In later attempts, I would slowly drift into sleep and even see HI (faces, detailed but very small scenes) occasionally. I also experienced a floating feeling in which there was only my mind and darkness. I could not feel my body at all. This, as well as the HI, made me jolt awake, with a very confused feeling (asking myself: “Wow, what the hell was that?!” ).
Up to now, I have not managed to get into a dream this way, neither ND nor LD. However, the attempts did seem to have an overall positive effect on being able to have LDs in the morning following the attempt (if only through “WILDing inside a dream”, see that topic for details).
Also, If I do not try too hard at getting anywhere, they do seem to have a positive effect on being able to fall asleep. After 15-30 mins of applying the technique, I am much more relaxed and don’t have as many thoughts which keep me awake.
If I am very tired when going to sleep, I tend to get to the HI stage and the floating feeling much easier, but the images and thoughts are very confusing and I never see any coherent scenes which I could enter. I eventually drift off to deep sleep.
I think the problem here is, I keep myself too awake, or I eventually fall into a phase of dreamless deep sleep. I am just too far from dreaming at the beginning of the sleep cycle, so this will probably not work for me.
2) Trying to WILD in the morning
This is a completely different experience. In fact, I do not have to do anything to relax before attempting to WILD in the morning. I often wake up, go to the bathroom, then return to bed and get into a comfortable position and try to drift back into sleep without losing awareness. Since counting keeps me too much awake, I like to focus my awareness on something tiny (like a glowing gem floating inside or above my head).
If I do not drift to sleep immediately (which tends to happen more often than I would like), I usually experience HI. These HI can be very detailed, fully colored and normal sized scenes. However, I am usually not able to enter them and they fade into darkness again after a couple of seconds. I then drift into a ND quickly, which may become a LD later on.
Autosuggestion shortly before the onset of HI seems to help a lot with inducing LDs. I get most of my LDs in the morning after having woken up once or twice. There has only been a single attempt so far where I was actually able to enter a scene and interact with it lucidly, at least for a very short time.
The problem here is probably that I tend to drift off into NDs since I am just too sleepy.
3) Trying to WILD during a nap
I have also tried this in the morning while being on a train. I just closed my eyes, listened to music and tried to relax. I also get quite detailed HI this way, after 15-20 mins, but I do not lose awareness of external sensory input either.
Once, I saw a computer screen in front of me and noticed I was actually reading ld4all forums. I then remembered that this could not be because I was sitting in a train, and surely enough, the HI faded and I woke up.
I think WILDing in naps during the day would be possible for me, but still difficult since it is difficult to lose complete awareness of the real world. I also seem to have some problems with the concept of sleeping deeply and dreaming in a train full of other people. Still, it is always fun to experiment!
So, what I think I have learned about WILD so far is this:
a) You have to fall asleep to have a LD, no matter what the technique may be. You won’t be dreaming if you keep yourself awake for hours. Don’t do it! If your WILD attempt does not seem to lead anywhere after about 30 min, roll over and try to fall asleep like you usually would. If you get too excited, this might keep you wide awake during the whole night, which is not good at all and will disrupt your sleep cycle. Also, you need to be aware of, but indifferent towards HI and strange feelings. If you are too surprised by them, they may cause you to wake up again.
b) WILD attempts are always worth the effort because you suggest to your SC that you want to dream, become lucid and also to have a successful WILD. Even if they do not work, they may result in LDs in any number of ways (remembering you were expecting to dream, dreaming about doing WILD, doing RCs etc.).
c) It makes a huge difference whether you attempt to WILD when first going to sleep or in the morning, after just waking up. Falling asleep is much simpler in the morning. It does not require a lot of effort to enter a dream if you have already slept for a few (3-6 is optimal for me) hours. The only problem is becoming lucid, but again, attempting to WILD seems to increase the chances.
So, to answer your questions Petter (if I have not already done so):
Most importantly, you have to fall asleep. If you can, try to stay aware, but also convince yourself that you are going to become lucid. It works.
If it is really bad, try not to think about dreaming at all. Follow your usual routine to fall asleep, get into a comfortable position in which you usually fall asleep fast and empty your head of thoughts. If all else fails, take a break from everything related to lucid dreaming for a day or two.
I think WILD attempts at the beginning of the sleep cycle can disrupt your usual sleep cycle badly by keeping you awake through the whole night (it has happened to me a few times). This can be damaging if you cannot sleep late in the morning.
Solution: Either do not attempt to WILD if you have to get up early the next morning, or limit your attempts strictly to a reasonable length (like 30 min at most), then go to sleep normally if you are not making any progress (lying in bed completely relaxed but wide awake is a dead-end situation since you probably will not fall asleep).